A metal roof lasts far longer than asphalt and stands up well to South Plains hail and wind, but it costs more up front, and the system you choose matters as much as the material. Standing-seam metal hides its fasteners under raised seams. Exposed-fastener panels are screwed through the face and cost less. This Old House's March 2026 guide lists metal at 40–70 years of life against 15–30 for asphalt shingles. Its national prices run about $4–$26 per square foot for exposed-fastener corrugated panels and $9–$30 for standing seam. Those are national figures, not Lubbock quotes.
Standing seam vs exposed fastener
These are two different roofs, and a quote that just says "metal roof" doesn't tell you which you are getting.
Standing seam. Panels run from eave to ridge and lock together at raised vertical seams, which Englert says are usually 12 to 24 inches apart. The fasteners sit under the seams, out of the weather. Ask how the system lets long panels expand and contract, usually with clips, because a South Plains roof goes from summer heat to winter freezes. Standing seam costs more and suits homes where you want the cleanest look and the fewest exposed holes.
Exposed fastener (through-fastened). Ribbed or corrugated panels, such as R-panel or 5V, are screwed straight through the panel face into the deck or purlins, each screw sealed with a rubber washer. Englert notes these are generally cheaper to install, and you will see them on many barns, shops and garages around Lubbock. The trade-off is that every screw is a hole through the roof sealed only by its washer. Ask the contractor what fastener checks and replacement the proposed panel will need over the years.
How metal handles Lubbock hail and wind
The Metal Roofing Alliance says hail will typically not penetrate a metal roof and that most metal roofing earns a UL 2218 Class 4 rating, the top impact class, tested by hitting a sample twice in the same spot with a 2-inch steel ball. MRA also notes that all roof types can show cosmetic damage in severe hail. On metal, that usually means dents.
Dents matter in two ways:
- Appearance. Thinner panels and softer metals dent more easily. Ask what gauge (thickness) and metal the quote includes.
- Insurance. Ask your agent whether your policy pays for dents that don't cause leaks, before you choose metal.
TDI says impact-resistant roofing that passes UL 2218 can earn premium credits, including formed metal panels, but each insurer sets its own discount. Ask your insurer which products qualify and what paperwork they need.
What goes under and around the panels
The panel is only the top layer. A complete metal roof quote also covers:
- Deck and tear-off. MRA notes metal can often be installed over an existing roof. Tearing off lets the contractor inspect and repair the deck. Ask which they recommend for your house and why.
- Underlayment. Ask which underlayment goes under the panels and whether it is rated for the heat that builds up under metal in direct sun.
- Trim and flashing. Eave, rake, ridge, valley and wall flashings are custom-bent pieces that do most of the waterproofing at the edges. They should match the panel system.
- Penetrations. Pipe boots made for metal, and a plan for vents, skylights and chimneys.
- Ventilation. A vented ridge and soffit intake, as on any roof.
- Coating. Ask which paint system and finish warranty come with the panels. MRA notes that cool-finish coatings reflect more sunlight, which can lower roof temperatures and cooling needs.
Cost compared with shingles
MRA puts a metal roof at roughly two to three times what an asphalt shingle roof costs. This Old House's October 2026 guide lists metal at about $19.30 per square foot nationally against about $5.16 for asphalt. The longer life can close some of that gap over time. Our metal vs shingles guide walks through the trade-offs, and the new roof cost guide covers what moves a price.
What a clear metal roofing quote lists
- the system (standing seam or exposed fastener) and panel profile;
- the metal, gauge, coating and color;
- clips or fastener type and spacing;
- tear-off or install-over, and how deck repairs are priced;
- underlayment brand and type;
- every trim and flashing piece, and how penetrations are handled;
- the manufacturer's finish warranty and any written workmanship warranty the contractor offers, as separate documents;
- the payment schedule.
Common questions
Is metal roofing worth it in Lubbock?
It often is if you plan to stay in the house a long time, since metal lasts much longer and resists hail punctures. If you may sell soon, the higher upfront cost is harder to recover. Compare both on the same scope.
Is a metal roof loud in hail or rain?
MRA says there is little difference between metal and other roofing materials when it comes to noise from rain or hail.
Does hail dent a metal roof?
Large hail can dent metal, especially thinner panels, even when it doesn't puncture. For damage after a storm, see hail damage roof repair.
Can a metal roof be installed over old shingles?
Often, according to MRA, but it depends on the deck's condition and the number of existing layers. A contractor should check before recommending it.
Sources: This Old House metal vs asphalt, Englert on standing seam vs exposed fastener, Metal Roofing Alliance on hail, TDI roofing discounts.
We connect Lubbock homeowners with independent local pros. You confirm the price and schedule directly with them.
Keep reading
- Roof repair
- Roof replacement
- Hail damage
- Roof leak repair
- Roof inspection
- What should a hail or wind inspection cover?
- Are Class 4 shingles worth considering?
- Metal or shingles for West Texas?
- What do I do after a hailstorm?
- What are the roof claim steps?
- Which contractor warning signs matter?
- What drives a new roof price?
- Which questions should I ask roofers?